[en] What is “Arctic governance”? A critical assessment of the diverse meanings of ‘Arctic governance’

Type de document

Auteur(s)

Instance

HALSHS

Est une partie de

Mots clés en

Humanities and Social Sciences/Political science
critical analysis
Arctic
efficiency
normativity
analytical framework
regimes
legitimacy
sovereignty
cooperation
governance

Date de publication

Langue du document

Anglais

Editeur

Brill
Nijhoff

Résumé

[en] The history of the concept of governance in Arctic social science does not necessarily take into account the process and degree of conceptualization pertaining to the subject or any semantic consistency in its use. Unlike the homogeneous or ‘taken-for-granted’ use of the concept by policy-makers in general, centered on a Westphalian or state- centered understanding of governance, the academic production on Arctic governance is characterized by four categories of approaches—pragmatic, prescriptive, functional and critical—which do not attempt to coincide with disciplinary borders or theoretical framework distinctions. The substantive goals of these approaches differ depending on the context—the likeliness of implementation, compliance with law, efficiency and effectiveness of processes, or the framing or re-framing of issues. Whereas not mutually exclusive, the four approaches contrast in the role they grant to law and normativity in the governance process, as well as in their assessment of effectiveness, and the specific- ity of the yardsticks used. This diversity leads to very contrasted assessment of governance. Although, economic governance is poorly investigated in governance studies, as well as the diverging views on governance amongst the actors concerned, the concept of governance has provided a valuable tool, affording complementary or contrasting insights, in understanding the state of the Arctic and anticipating its future.

Nom de la revue

The Yearbook of Polar Law

Collection

Source

HAL

Type de ressource

Notice

Licence

Distributed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License

Citation bibliographique

Cecile Pelaudeix. What is “Arctic governance”? A critical assessment of the diverse meanings of ‘Arctic governance’. The Yearbook of Polar Law, 2015, The Yearbook of Polar Law, 6 (2014), pp.398-426. [halshs-01132866]

Citer cette ressource

[en] What is “Arctic governance”? A critical assessment of the diverse meanings of ‘Arctic governance’, dans Études nordiques, consulté le 16 Avril 2025, https://etudes-nordiques.cnrs.fr/s/numenord/item/18305